Taylor Swift was not quite finished with The Life of a Showgirl. On September 25, 2026, she released The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore, adding four completely new songs to the album: “Patient Zero,” “Cleveland!,” “Pink Clouding,” and “Babylon.” Swift wrote the tracks after the original album’s release while reconnecting with longtime collaborators Max Martin and Shellback in Sweden.
The four songs cover very different ground. There is relationship fallout, nostalgia, self-reflection, and a noticeably happier look at Swift’s current life. That also makes ranking them surprisingly difficult, because none of the tracks feels like it was added simply to fill space.
Still, somebody has to come in fourth.
4. "Cleveland!"
“Cleveland!” is probably the most immediately recognizable product of Swift’s current chapter. The song has been widely interpreted as a nod to Travis Kelce, who grew up in the Cleveland area, and it leans into the lighter, more playful side of the Showgirl era.
There is something fun about hearing Swift write from a place that feels less tortured than much of her past relationship material. The problem is that “Cleveland!” has tougher competition here. Compared with the storytelling on “Patient Zero” or the atmosphere of “Babylon,” it feels a little more straightforward.
It is catchy, personal, and likely to become a fan favourite for people who prefer Swift when she is having fun. Among these four songs, though, it is the one we are least likely to keep replaying first.
3. “Pink Clouding”
“Pink Clouding” feels much closer to classic reflective Taylor Swift territory. The track looks backward at a relationship with a mixture of regret and perspective, focusing less on assigning blame and more on what becomes obvious once enough time has passed.
That makes it one of the more interesting additions to The Encore. Swift has spent years writing songs about relationships while she is still emotionally inside them. “Pink Clouding” instead feels like someone examining an old version of herself from a distance.
It is quieter than some of the other new tracks, which may keep it from becoming the obvious breakout. Give it a few listens, though, and it starts making a stronger case for itself.
2. “Babylon”
“Babylon” might be the biggest grower of the four.
Built around nostalgia, leaving places behind, and the uneasy feeling that comes with wondering what could have happened differently, the song has the sort of emotional ambiguity Swift handles particularly well.
There is no simple villain or neat resolution to latch onto. Instead, “Babylon” lives in that uncomfortable space where moving forward does not necessarily mean you stop thinking about what you left behind.
It also feels slightly removed from the glossy personality of The Life of a Showgirl, which works in its favour. Rather than trying to extend one of the album’s biggest moments, “Babylon” creates its own little world.
If “Patient Zero” had not arrived with such a strong concept, this easily could have taken the top spot.
1. "Patient Zero"
“Patient Zero” is the clear standout.
The song uses the language of illness and infection to describe the damage left behind by a toxic relationship. Instead of concentrating only on Swift’s experience, the premise connects her with another woman who has apparently encountered the same person and the same patterns.
It is a clever idea because it gives Swift a different relationship dynamic to explore. This is not simply another song aimed at an ex. At its centre is the strange bond that can form between two people who suddenly realize they have been dealing with different versions of the same problem.
Swift clearly sees potential in the song beyond the recording itself. She also directed its music video, starring Dakota Johnson and Colin Farrell, which premiered during the 2026 MTV Video Music Awards.
The concept is memorable, the chorus sticks, and the song gives listeners plenty to unpack without feeling like it was engineered purely to generate theories about Swift’s past.
The Final Ranking
-
“Patient Zero”
-
“Babylon”
-
“Pink Clouding”
-
“Cleveland!”
Four new songs could have easily felt like an afterthought attached to an already successful album. Instead, The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore adds a surprisingly varied final chapter, moving between Swift’s past and present without simply repeating what the original album already did.
“Patient Zero” may have gotten the biggest introduction, but “Babylon” and “Pink Clouding” are exactly the kind of tracks that could quietly climb fans’ rankings after a few more listens. And knowing Swift’s fanbase, this order will probably be debated almost immediately.
